So I packed this guy and wasn't too happy but thought "he fits in my team, might as well give him a go". By god he is a tank, he is always saving me ass when I make a mistake or when my SIF Ginter decides to be an idiot.
Defensively amazing: Will pretty much always make the challenge you need
Physical: Has amazing strength and jumping, so almost always out strengths the opposition or out jumps them.
Passing: I've had other defenders who when they've made a challenge they then pass the ball straight back to the other team, Otamendi has 92 short pass and 86 long pass so he always manages to clear his lines
Pace: without an anchor or shadow chem style, he is woefully slow
Shooting: He's a defender so who cares, although he did score a bicycle kick for me once