Reviews

Malcom - 89 - TOTS
4.5
4* Weak foot? Yeah right....
By Demilios, 28-04-2018

Hello everyone,


I'm sure that I'm not the only one who got very excited when we saw that Malcom was in the most consistent TOTS this FIFA. I saw his stats and thought I need this card especially since it has 4 * weak foot, which later turned out to seem more like a 3/2* ingame for some reason. Now to actually get into the review;


[Pace] This man is fast really, really, really fast this due to his pace (99 Acceleration, 91 Sprint Speed with Hawk chem style) mixed in with 99 Agility and 95 Balance if you're somewhat of a decent player you should easily get in behind with this card.


[Shooting] Good, nothing more, nothing less. His shooting won't let you down, but don't expect to bang in every shot. Especially not with his right foot which I previously mentioned as being quite a weird thing he has where it feels like he's Robben one game and can't score a single one with his right, and the next game he bangs a volley out of the box in with his right.


[Passing] Unlike the previously mentioned bad right foot with shooting this isn't really seen in his passing. Crosses are good, passes are good.


[Dribbling] Outstanding. With 99 Agility, 95 Balance, 86 Reactions, 90 Ball Control and 94 Dribbling this guy is one of the best when it comes to dribbling. Cutting inside becomes easy as he glides past the opponents defenders, and just when you thought: "Ah crap I'm going to get tackled" he jumps over the defenders legs and slides it in the net.


[Defending] He has 91 heading for a winger, but don't be fooled he doesn't win headers sadly. He can score headers yeah, but only when the cross is good. He also intercepted quite a few balls for me even though his defending stats are all in the 20's, might just be because of his pace.


[Physical] I've gotta say 78 Jumping, 77 Strength and 69 Aggresion (With Hawk chem style) aren't any stats to write home about, yet he seems to bully off fullbacks like Bellerin and Jordi Alba sometimes don't expect anything though because when he does get caught he goes down 9/10 times. 86 Stamina is good, but I personally subbed him out in the 75~ish minute so take that in account when you look at my goals and assists.


[Overall] This is a great card to have in your squad. He doesn't always do what you want to do, but he has something which quite a few players don't have and that is a Fun Factor as I like to call it. What Fun Factor means is that even though he's not always performing on his best (Weird 4* WF thing, Goes down easily, and doesn't win headers) he's fun to use. It's a great feeling when you cut inside and make defenders struggle to keep up.


I hope this review helps you in any way.


Demilios~

[Pace] Like mentioned before very fast.


[Shooting] Just good.


[Passing] Gives some really nice crosses and passes.


[Dribbling] Very agile and fast on the dribble + 4* skills.


Fun Factor; Fun to use imo.



4* weak foot feels like 3/2* most of the time.


Goes down easily.


Has 91 headers but doesn't really win them at all.

Formation: 4321
Position: RF
Games: 6
GPG: 0.83
APG: 0.33
4.5
Overall
4.0
Value
4.0
GC
3.5
Stamina
Pace (10/10)
Shooting (8/10)
Passing (8/10)
Dribbling (10/10)
Defending (4/10)
Physicality (6/10)
4.5
Better than expected.
By fortheberds, 30-04-2018

He was in one of my saved packs, I got him and immediately thought, how much can I sell him for? But with WL upon us I figured I would give him a shot and write a review. Boy let me tell you, I was overly impressed after I figured out how to use him. The first 5 games I played I was doing what people normally do with new fast cards, force the ball to him and try to take on every defender with the sprint button held. Nothing was working(in 5 games, I had 4G 1A, so kinda meh) so then I went back to playing how I normally do and that's when he came alive. He reminded me of Dybala of last year, super clinical, very technical with the ball and just had that magic, not to say Dybala's not good this year, but last year he had something about him.


He always seems to be in the right position I played him at LCAM in a 4231, now on to the Pros/Cons

Pace: Simple, his acceleration makes him pull away very easily, he reminds me of Insigne, the break away is great but with only 86 sprint speed it's short lived. So if you can find your next course of action with the 2 yards of space you just grabbed with him, you'll be fine.


Shooting: Long shots, check. Finesse shots, check. Heading, extra check! Heading was exquisite, he always seemed to out jump the LBl/RB he was facing, didn't matter who it was, he won the ball. The only problem I had with his shooting was he was sometimes not in the best position to take a shot when I wanted him to, even though his positioning is 90, I feel like it's more of an 83.


Passing: Like I said I forced the ball to him early on and nothing was working. But after I started playing normally, let me tell you this guys passing is just as good as PTG Willians if not better. He always passes it into safe areas, even when I would force a through ball to the striker of my central CAM, he would always lead them correctly, or play to the foot that was away from the defender. I think his passing was the most impressive out of a card that I wasn't expecting to be the best passer.


Dribbling: Plain and simple. Dribbling is phenomenal. It says 93 it is a 93, easily.


Defending: Comes back on defense quite a lot, not the worst thing from an outside CAM with 85 strength to help shack up the defense.


Physicality: 72 Strength, feels like 85 in the box easily, with his dribbling combo very hard to relieve him of the ball.

Only 2 major cons come to mind when I played with him.


Defending: He would sometimes switch positions with the LCDM and stay back, which would severely disrupt my play when out wide I'm expecting a pacy guy and all of a sudden, bam, Petit is outwide with the ball, taking on a RB.


Physicality: Definitely not 86 stamina, by the 80th minute this dude is a little gassed, but to be honest the damage he deals in those first 80 minutes is enough.


Overall this card is a 9/10 for me. Would definitely buy, but I'd draw the line at about 160k, not worth the 200k.

Formation: 4231
Position: CAM
Games: 32
GPG: 0.53
APG: 0.91
4.5
Overall
4.5
Value
4.5
GC
4.0
Stamina
Pace (10/10)
Shooting (8/10)
Passing (10/10)
Dribbling (8/10)
Defending (5/10)
Physicality (9/10)
4.5
The Brazilian Messi
By Pacenzo, 03-05-2018

Malcom is just fantastic, everything is lovely! His pace, his shooting, his movement. I have played him with, Suarez, Kün Agüero and IF Jesus. He will make the perfect run at all time, I have more than double goal contributions to games with Malcom. I have both played him on 10 and 7 chem and I cant feel any difference. His dribbling is like Messi style... is just amazing! The shoot is.... BANG!!! Incredible shooting with is left foot and also with is right foot. Very OP player!

  • PACE
  • DRIBBLING (AMAZING!!!)
  • SHOOT IN EVERY POSITION
  • NO CONS
Formation: 4321
Position: RF
Games: 50
GPG: 0.60
APG: 0.40
4.5
Overall
4.0
Value
4.5
GC
4.0
Stamina
Pace (9/10)
Shooting (9/10)
Passing (8/10)
Dribbling (10/10)
Defending (5/10)
Physicality (7/10)
4.0
Amazing and versatile attacker
By ratbagsson, 04-05-2018

Malcom is one of the best dribblers I've used in FIFA 18. His agility and ability to weave between defenders is absolutely exemplary. He finishes very well on his left foot, with any finesse shot from the edge of the box nestling in the top corner, and any low driven sliding under the keeper's arm. His right foot is consistent as well, but often lacks power. He has a very solid passing ability, especially with shorter-distance passes. He lacks strength and height, as well as an ability to burst in behind the defense; he doesn't get himself into a lot of 1v1's. He is certainly usable as a LS in a 2-striker formation, but I believe he would be best suited as a CAM or LCAM.

  • acceleration
  • finishing
  • finesse shots
  • agility
  • dribbling/close control
  • skill move execution
  • strength/power
  • height
  • running in behind
Formation: 41212-2
Position: ST
Games: 8
GPG: 1.13
APG: 1.13
4.0
Overall
3.0
Value
3.5
GC
3.5
Stamina
Pace (8/10)
Shooting (8/10)
Passing (9/10)
Dribbling (9/10)
Defending (5/10)
Physicality (6/10)