I recently changed my defense which meant I needed a Bundesliga GK. So of course I went for Neuer and I was very happy to find he's an amazing keeper this year. I have Courtouis untradeable and I'm going to have to go back to him when I eventually get TOTY Varane, so believe that I'm unbiased in saying that I prefer Neuer. I just trust Neuer way more in those scruffy situations which you always have to be prepared for in this game. And that's important because lots of top tier GK's have pretty much 99 in everything with a basic anyway so I'm looking for a calm and collected goalie which Neuer fits perfectly. I felt Courtouis could be a bit clumsy at times in comparison. The fact he's way better at kicking and has 4* WF also makes me feel way more comfortable when controlling him too.
Great rounded keeper
Just "not bad", which is rare in GK's