i have baby eto'o untradeable and for me atal is miles better. both of their shooting is exceptional, and both of their passing are relatively poor compared to neymar for example (personally, this is just my experience). atal can also defend of course which is a nice bonus but not really that important. they are both good, but atal having 5*5* compared to eto'o 4*4* is what makes him a lot better.