Accessibility
Home
Players
Evolutions
Squad Builder
SBCs
Draft
Squads
Market
News
Packs
Objectives
Token Tracker
More
Language
Platform
Theme
EA Tax Calculator

Reviews

86 - Icon
4.5
R. Carlos-"first choice"
By Strassenfussballer, 04-11-2019

What can i say, R. Carlos is a man of "firsts" for me. Like for many, he is my first icon in F20.

He blew me away so much in just a handful of games that made me write this review - which is also a first to me - so please be kind.


As most of you probably i struggled immensly on what kind of icons select from Swap (chapeau EA: this is great as no one wants to see all the same opponent squads throughout WL).

For me was always clear to take a defender and it came down to waiting for Zanetti or taking R.Carlos (and Nesta). To make sure, i got him first on transfer and than directly afterwards decided to get him from swaps (so you may not have to do this anymore after this review hopefully and save yourself the tax).

I played Carlos in three different positions and formations. As LB in a 4-2-3-1, LM in 3-5-2 and as LAM.


R. Carlos does what he was known for. He is incredible fast, is able to get back to everyone - even the likes of lacazette etc. But he is not only fast but his strong physic helps to make short process of everyone. In this Fifa he fits the meta for backs and i felt like my left side was safe having him back there. Nevertheless the true strength is the offence - next to his strong balance and agility (which just feels amazing) his pinpoint passing and acceleration make him a true weapon which is why he will not play very often in his original position for me. I am really in love with 3-5-2 this year and since there have been many great options for the the RM (scream Navas is my first choice here) - i was directly having R. Carlos as coutnerpart in mind. And he does it just perfectly. Wherever I need him - offence or defence - he is there.The funny thing is that somehow you dont see him often, but when i needed him (like twice in last 10 Min in WL), he is there to provide the last pass or finish himself - and that so clinically. His leftfood is just a hammer. I know many will be offset with his 2*WF and 3*SM, but this is no dealbreaker for me at all - even at CAM. While i personally rely not much on dribbling skills (and find it quite annoying sometimes), the weak foot is not really noticeable and similar with last years robben, i even believe that it make the playing experience with RC better and realistic. With his overall package he is just pure joy to play and dribble. He reminds me a little of last years Birthday-Salah and the TOTS-Dybala from 2018 - moving him in the midfield (especially as CAM) is so precise and especially when you like to quickly outpass your opponent and move from the side to the center he is pure gold.



Freekicks: Ok, never would have though that i would ever specifially mention FKs. But i guess writting about R. Carlos and not mentioning Freekicks would be weird. What can i say - again a first. Directly in my first freekick he nailed it directly in the corner. Needless to say: also the first time i scored a direct FK. In all honesty, RC just opened up for me taking direct FKs at all - normally i wouldnt have even looked at the stats as i find the system this year just awful. But RC is just amazing. I dont know if it is just so fantastic in my head because i like to recreate old plays and love the idea to score FKs with RC (btw, any chances for a juninho icon EA?), but since i have RC i scored two more direct FKs and hit at least 3 times the crossbar. I feel a little like in 2018 where after being in a good position i was confident that this could lead to a real chance.


Summary: RC has it all. He is the most solid Defender you possibly could get for LB - but could literally play every other position except GK. His speed, precise dribbling and shot power make him a great package, and an amazing CAM option as well. Not only did he open FKs as an option for me but gives me real joy - it is just real fun to play him. So on many accounts a first for me and i know I will enjoy him for a long time. As you may see, the stats are not so impressive. These are from the swap version and only from this WL. So if you are still doubting on which icon to take. I fullheartedly can recommend him, and you still have the opportunity to take another icon as well.

  • Defence: He is a pain for every attacker whether they are fast or strong
  • Agility and dribbling: Both offence and defensiv, he just wiggles though anyone and just feels so direct and responsive
  • Pace: He gets the ball - and is gone. Wheter in the center field or outside one long ball or double pass and wooosh
  • Clutch af: if he gets the ball on his left foot close to ball, decide which kind of celebration you want to do (or just quickly skip it - no one likes a boaster)
  • Phyicality: Hight is this year (for now) not necessary for a back and in all other physical aspects RC is just a beast. When playing in defence he is just a monster with his physicality and speed. I had it so often that he so easily muscled out attackers after rushing down half of the field that it almost felt unfair.
  • Freekick!! see above


  • 3*Skill moves: In my opinion he is still one of the best CAM options you have at this point of the game. If you love to use skill moves he is not your first choice.
  • 2*Weak foot: So far i havent seen many letdowns here. He has a rocket as left foot, so if you make sure you use it adequately RC will never let you down. In my opinion the way you will use him this is no downer as you will come in shooting positings with him either after coutnerattack where he has enough space to score in box or with distance shot where you will make sure to use his strong food anyways.
  • Hair? I am serious guys, I try to be as tough as i can on him. This would be the only real let-down here. An RC with afro just doesnt give you the right feels :P
Formation: 352
Position: LM
Games: 13
GPG: 0.31
APG: 0.08
4.5
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
GC
4.0
Stamina
Pace (10/10)
Shooting (8/10)
Passing (8/10)
Dribbling (9/10)
Defending (10/10)
Physicality (10/10)
5.0
HES EVERYWHERE
By BigRigRigBig, 24-11-2019

This guy is exceptional. like i said he is everywhere, he controls the left side of the pitch running back and forth all by himself. One second you attack with him next second he is back in defense making a tackle. you probably wouldn't even need a LM or LW. He is super fast with the ball at his feet that players cant touch him. But one thing stood aside from the rest of the pros about him, his Free Kicks. We all know how difficult it can be to score free kicks in this game but this guy makes it look easy. If placed right Roberto Carlos will probably score every single free kick. Any way i would HIGHLY recommend doing him in icon swaps.

Work Rates

Free Kicks

Speed Dribbling


2 Star Weak Foot

Formation: 433
Position: LB
Games: 105
GPG: 0.19
APG: 0.63
5.0
Overall
5.0
Value
4.0
GC
4.5
Stamina
Pace (10/10)
Shooting (8/10)
Passing (7/10)
Dribbling (8/10)
Defending (9/10)
Physicality (8/10)
5.0
Roberto Carlos is worth the effort!!!
By Dekayman, 20-11-2019

When ICON Swaps were released and I was going through the challanges I definitly wanted to go for Butragueno because of its pace, shooting and 5* weak foot. BUT then I changed my mind and was going for R.Carlos and Nesta to get a solid defensive line. To me it was clear to first aim for R.Carlos because back in the days I loved to see him play and his left foot was not from this planet (I'm a left foot player as well :D). But now let's talk about his abilitys.


I play him in a 4-1-2-1-2 (2) formation as LB with Militao, Lenglet and Walker on defense. I was pretty hyped about his pace and he didn't disappointed me at all. For most LBs like Robertson, Angelino and Roussillion it's nearly impossible to get after a fast RW when you don't have a perfect positioning. But R.Carlos is fast as hell and he doesn't get only after the attacker he gets the ball as well so easiely. I really love his tackling style and how he runs. The only thing I could complain about him is his high rated attacking work rate. Sometimes when you go forward R.Carlos runs down the line like he is a LW (I always use player instructions to let my LB and RB "Stay back while attacking").


In fact you only need 11 ICON Swaps itmes R.Carlos is really worth the effort and you should aim for him if you wanna upgrade your defense. I really think he is the first player I will set in my starting 11 for the rest of FIFA 20.

fast as hell

gets after attackers

great tackling style

left hammer

attacking work rate

Formation: 41212-2
Position: LB
Games: 9
GPG: 0.00
APG: 0.00
5.0
Overall
5.0
Value
4.5
GC
4.5
Stamina
Pace (10/10)
Shooting (7/10)
Passing (7/10)
Dribbling (7/10)
Defending (10/10)
Physicality (9/10)
5.0
Carlos - best FK specialist in game
By TJdor, 20-11-2019

So there are some reviews here so I will be as short as possible. I'm an Elite player with a free2play account and i had to get creative to stand a chance vs PayCardFC(you can see my squad in description).Played fifa pro back in the days but not anymore. I played Carlos over 200 matches and tested him in every position except GK and he stands as one of my mains threats when i go online.


First of all in this fifa wingbacks are kind of super fast defenders that have to get the ball quick and have a decent pass.Carlos is not ideal because of his workrates H/M (even on stay back and agg interceptions he is not aggresive when coming to get the ball for me at least). That's kind of it. If you want a beast of a defender pick Zanetti and be done with the swaps. He is end game CB/LB/RB/CDM, but he lacks shooting!


Second - the most expensive players in the game are B2B midfielders because they need to have high attributes on all. So here is where Robi Carlos shines. He is an insane distance shooter, and even with his finishing at 77 you won't feel it like that in the box(played him striker many times and he bangs them) because of awesome 99 shot power 96 long shots and 88 curve (with maestro chemistry). He is fluid and very fast as everyone tells you and can defend like a beast cuz of that. He will be everywhere on the field if you let him on balance as a RCM (yes Right cuz he shoots with left). He usually has most interceptions in the game. The key on making the most of this card is knowing how to attack and when to shoot with him. IF Messi's left is the best for finesse, Carlos's left is the best for ripping the ball in the net from 16m+. He saved me more than once in WL vs that insane dropback defence from that range. (btw don't shot with his right, can score easy ones in the box with it but in rest it sucks). The week foot is manageable if you play him in RCM/RM/RW positions. He shines when he has to cut in and shoot. If you need more than 3* SM with a midfielder then you are doing something very wrong imho so I won't even mention it as a weakness.


3rd - there is only one chemistry that i recommend and that is Maestro(not in defense - there Anchor is best - no one will ever outrun you). He needs the long shot upgrade, the passing, extra dribbling is always good in high pace cards and THE FK UPGRADE. I'm not even lying he scored for me over 20 goals from FK in like 30 shots in WL. Once he moved his GK there and he had a defender too and still got in LOL. He is that great! Just practice them and you will love it. So Maestro everywhere in the middle! (Deadeye if you play him as a Striker but there are others good there because he has the WF and low composure!)

Best FK specialist in FIFA20 (with maestro)

Insane Pace and Dribbling

Insane Left Foot and Long Distance shooting (with maestro)

Work Rates are very good for the offensive RCM(he is everywhere on the pitch on balance)

Best played in RCM/RM positions because of week foot

WF is 2

Formation: 442
Position: CM
Games: 100
GPG: 0.33
APG: 0.44
5.0
Overall
5.0
Value
4.5
GC
5.0
Stamina
Pace (10/10)
Shooting (9/10)
Passing (8/10)
Dribbling (9/10)
Defending (8/10)
Physicality (8/10)
2.5
Mediocre LB
By HarryFifaGR, 09-02-2020

bobby was considered as an incredible offer on fut swaps. I decided to complete him, though i regretted my choice after 10 games. he loses too many 1v1s due to his tiny body and his pace isnt visible ingame. he is always off position and led me to conceding goald from the wing. I dont suggest buying him as i believe he isnt worth it at all. buy mendy, alaba, robertson, telles instead.

Pace, free kicks

Def, awareness, body type, height, 1v1 situations

Formation: 41212-2
Position: LB
Games: 40
GPG: 0.08
APG: 0.33
2.5
Overall
0.5
Value
1.0
GC
4.0
Stamina
Pace (8/10)
Shooting (7/10)
Passing (9/10)
Dribbling (7/10)
Defending (2/10)
Physicality (1/10)